
From JDSupra, Matthew Nelson and Alexandra Nielsen provide guidance for foreign employers engaging with workers in the United States who might be independent contractors. Matthew and Alexandra write:
In the United States, worker classification turns on the substance of the working relationship, not the label selected by the parties. For foreign employers entering or expanding in the US market, an incorrect classification can create wage-and-hour, tax, benefits and other compliance exposure across multiple jurisdictions.
Two distinct classification questions
A hiring company should distinguish between two inquiries that are often conflated. The first is whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor. That threshold determination affects the application of wage-and-hour protections, payroll-tax requirements and other employment obligations.
If the worker is an employee, a separate question follows: whether the employee is exempt or non-exempt from overtime requirements. Salary and job title alone do not determine exempt status, which generally depends on satisfying both an applicable compensation requirement and the relevant duties test.
Which classification rules apply?
Under federal wage law, agencies and courts apply an “economic reality” test, which asks whether the worker is genuinely in business for themselves or instead is economically dependent on the company that engaged them. The governing framework is currently in transition: in February 2026, the US Department of Labor proposed replacing its 2024 rule with an analysis that gives greater weight to two core factors, the nature and degree of control over the work and the worker’s opportunity for profit or loss based on initiative or investment. Other relevant considerations include the skill required, the permanence of the relationship and whether the work is part of an integrated unit of production. Because the federal standard may continue to evolve, companies should confirm the rule and controlling case law in effect when making or reviewing a classification decision.
Federal tax authorities apply a separate control-based analysis that considers behavioral control, financial control the parties’ relationship. Classification affects tax withholding and reporting: employees generally receive Form W-2, while qualifying independent contractors generally receive Form 1099-NEC. Issuing a Form 1099-NEC does not determine a worker’s legal status. If the facts establish an employment relationship, tax authorities may assess unpaid taxes, interest and applicable penalties.
State law may impose a more demanding standard. California, Massachusetts and New Jersey, among other jurisdictions, use versions of an “ABC test” for certain purposes. Subject to statutory exceptions and jurisdiction-specific rules, these tests generally presume employee status unless the company establishes that: (A) the worker is free from the company’s control and direction in performing the work; (B) the work falls outside the usual course of the company’s business; and (C) the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature. Prong B is frequently a significant obstacle when the worker performs services central to the company’s business.
Because these tests operate independently, the same worker can be an independent contractor under one and an employee under another and the result can change with the state in which the work is performed—so a single classification applied across a multistate workforce may be correct in one jurisdiction and wrong in another.
What can misclassification cost?
A worker who should have been treated as an employee may assert claims for unpaid minimum wages, overtime, expense reimbursement, benefits, or other statutory protections, depending on the governing law. The company may also face liability for unpaid payroll taxes, unemployment-insurance and workers’ compensation contributions, interest, penalties and, in some circumstances, liquidated damages and attorneys’ fees.
Exposure is not limited to a single worker or forum: federal and state labor and tax agencies may each pursue classification issues, private litigants may bring related claims and where the same classification model has been applied across a workforce, liability can extend well beyond one relationship.[1]
What should foreign companies do?
Classification is best addressed as part of the hiring process and revisited as the relationship develops, rather than after a dispute or agency inquiry arises. Companies should:
- Classify each worker based on the actual working relationship, not contractual terminology or home-jurisdiction practice.
- Analyze employee-versus-contractor status separately from exempt-versus-non-exempt status.
- Review existing contractor relationships, particularly where contractors perform core business functions or work in substantially the same manner as employees.
- Identify the law applicable in each state where workers perform services.
- Revisit classifications as working relationships evolve, including changes in responsibilities, duration, integration, or company control.
- Consider the appropriate infrastructure for early US hires, including whether direct employment or an Employer of Record arrangement better suits the company’s plans.
[1]US. Government Accountability Office, Employee Misclassification: Improved Coordination, Outreach and Targeting Could Better Ensure Detection and Prevention, GAO-09-717 (August 2009) (discussing the respective roles of the US Department of Labor, Internal Revenue Service and state agencies in addressing worker classification).





